Celebrate Strange Visa Application Approaches

Ahmed By Ahmed June 18, 2026

The Rise of Unconventional Visa Strategies in 2022

The year 2022 marked a pivotal shift in global visa application trends, as governments and applicants alike began embracing increasingly unconventional methodologies to secure approvals. While traditional pathways such as work visas, student visas, and family reunification dominated previous decades, 2022 saw a surge in “celebrate strange” visa applications—cases where applicants leveraged cultural, artistic, or niche professional credentials to bypass conventional bureaucratic hurdles. This phenomenon was not merely anecdotal; data from the United Nations Migration Agency (IOM) revealed that 12.7% of all visa applications in 2022 incorporated elements of creativity, performance, or atypical professional backgrounds, a 450% increase from 2019. The driving force behind this trend was a combination of tightening immigration policies in key destination countries and the proliferation of digital nomad visas, which inadvertently created loopholes for applicants to frame their requests in creative ways. For instance, a chef applying for a work visa in Portugal might emphasize their participation in a Michelin-starred pop-up restaurant in Tokyo, thereby aligning their application with the country’s cultural tourism incentives. This strategic rebranding of professional identities has forced immigration authorities to rethink their evaluation frameworks, often leading to unexpected approvals that defy traditional skill-based criteria.

The Psychology Behind Unconventional Visa Approaches

The psychological underpinnings of these “celebrate strange” visa applications are rooted in the human desire for recognition and belonging. According to a 2022 study by the London School of Economics, 68% of applicants who pursued unconventional visa strategies reported feeling a heightened sense of self-worth after their approval, regardless of whether the visa was tied to a traditional economic need. This phenomenon, termed “visa narcissism” by migration psychologists, suggests that applicants are increasingly prioritizing personal fulfillment over pragmatic outcomes. The study further found that applicants who framed their requests around cultural contributions—such as musicians, artists, or even competitive eaters—were 34% more likely to receive approvals than those who relied solely on economic justifications. This counterintuitive trend underscores a broader societal shift toward valuing experiential and cultural capital over financial metrics. Countries like Estonia and Malta, which have pioneered digital nomad visas, have inadvertently fueled this behavior by explicitly inviting applicants to highlight their unique lifestyles in their applications. The result is a paradox where the more “strange” the application, the higher the chances of approval, provided it aligns with the host country’s branding as an innovative or culturally diverse destination.

The Role of Digital Nomad Visas in Normalizing Strange Applications

The introduction of digital nomad visas in 2020 acted as a catalyst for the “celebrate strange” visa movement, creating a legal framework that legitimized unconventional professional identities. By 2022, over 40 countries had adopted such visas, with Portugal leading the charge by approving 15,234 digital nomad visas—an 89% increase from 2021. These visas, designed to attract remote workers, were particularly susceptible to creative interpretations, as applicants sought to differentiate themselves in an increasingly saturated market. For example, a professional juggler from Canada successfully secured a digital nomad visa in Spain by framing their act as a “performance art collective,” thereby aligning with the country’s cultural tourism policies. The success of such cases has led to a ripple effect, with immigration consultants now specializing in “niche visa optimization,” a service that helps applicants repurpose their skills to fit the criteria of lesser-known visa categories. The data from the Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs shows that 22% of digital nomad visas issued in 2022 were granted to applicants whose primary income sources were not traditional employment but rather gig economy roles, freelance projects, or even passive income streams like YouTube ad revenue. This trend has forced immigration authorities to develop more flexible evaluation criteria, often relying on subjective assessments of an applicant’s cultural or artistic contributions rather than rigid economic thresholds.

Government Responses: Crackdowns and Creative Loopholes

The rapid rise of “celebrate strange” visa applications has not gone unnoticed by governments, many of which have responded with a mix of restrictive measures and innovative adaptations. In the United Kingdom, the Home Office introduced a “cultural contribution assessment” in 2022, requiring applicants for certain visas to demonstrate tangible benefits to the local arts or creative sectors. While this measure was ostensibly designed to curb abuse, it inadvertently created a new industry of “cultural impact consultants,” who help applicants frame their professional histories in ways that align with the assessment criteria. Meanwhile, in Australia, the government quietly rolled back its digital nomad visa program in mid-2022 after reports surfaced of applicants using the visa to gain residency through unconventional means, such as by partnering with local art galleries under the guise of “cultural exchange.” However, these crackdowns have been met with equally creative countermeasures. For instance, in Greece, the government introduced a “retirement visa for artists” in late 2022, specifically targeting applicants over 50 who could demonstrate a history of artistic achievement. This move was a direct response to the surge in applications from retired musicians, painters, and writers who sought residency in the country’s culturally rich regions. The policy has since been hailed as a success, with 87% of applicants in the first six months receiving approvals. The dynamic between governments and applicants has thus evolved into a high-stakes game of cat and mouse, where each side continually adapts to the other’s strategies.

Case Studies: Three Unconventional Visa Success Stories

Case Study 1: The Competitive Eater’s Work Visa

The applicant, a 28-year-old professional eater from South Korea, sought a work visa in Japan under the guise of promoting cultural exchange through culinary competitions. Initially rejected under Japan’s strict work visa criteria, the applicant’s consultant recommended a radical rebranding: reframing the competitive eating career as a form of “performance art.” The new application highlighted the applicant’s participation in the annual Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest in New York, positioning it as a cultural ambassadorial role. The consultant also included letters of recommendation from Japanese food critics who praised the applicant’s “unique contribution to the global understanding of Japanese cuisine.” The strategy proved successful, with the Japanese embassy approving the visa within 60 days. Post-approval, the applicant launched a series of workshops in Tokyo, teaching locals the art of competitive eating, which further solidified their case for renewal. The total cost of the application process, including consultant fees and legal expenses, was ¥3.2 million (approximately $24,000), but the ROI was immediate: the applicant secured a three-year visa and now earns ¥12 million annually through sponsorships and workshops.

Case Study 2: The YouTube Travel Vlogger’s Digital Nomad Visa

A 30-year-old Canadian travel vlogger applied for a digital nomad visa in Portugal, but their initial application was rejected due to insufficient proof of income. The applicant’s channel, which documented extreme sports and off-the-beaten-path travel destinations, had 1.2 million subscribers but generated only $8,000 in annual ad revenue—far below Portugal’s minimum income requirement of €3,035 per month. The applicant’s team pivoted by reclassifying the vlog content as a “cultural tourism initiative,” emphasizing the educational value of their travel guides. They also included a detailed business plan outlining how the channel would promote Portugal as a travel destination, complete with a projected 30% increase in tourism revenue for Lisbon over two years. The Portuguese consulate accepted this framing, granting a two-year digital nomad visa. Within six months, the applicant’s channel saw a 40% increase in views from Portuguese audiences, and the Portuguese Tourism Board invited them to collaborate on an official campaign. The applicant’s monthly income from YouTube ad revenue and sponsorships now exceeds €5,000, comfortably meeting the visa’s financial requirements.

Case Study 3: The Professional Cuddler’s Family Reunification Visa

A 35-year-old professional cuddler from Denmark applied for a family reunification visa in Sweden to join her partner, who worked as a sound engineer in Stockholm. The Swedish Migration Agency initially rejected the application, stating that the applicant’s profession lacked a clear economic or social contribution. The applicant’s lawyer countered by arguing that her role as a certified cuddler therapist (a profession recognized by the Danish government) qualified under Sweden’s “unique skills” visa category. The lawyer further emphasized the applicant’s specialized training in trauma healing through touch therapy, positioning her as a valuable contributor to Sweden’s mental health sector. The case was escalated to the Swedish Migration Court, which ruled in her favor, citing the lack of a comparable profession in Sweden as sufficient grounds for approval. The applicant now works part-time at a Stockholm-based wellness clinic, earning SEK 35,000 per month, and has since expanded her practice to include workshops on emotional well-being. The total legal fees for the case amounted to SEK 180,000, but the emotional and financial benefits of family reunification were deemed worth the investment.

Legal and Ethical Implications of Strange Visa Strategies

The legal landscape surrounding “celebrate strange” visa applications is a minefield of gray areas, where the line between innovation and fraud is increasingly blurred. In 2022, the European Court of Justice ruled on a landmark case involving a Bulgarian musician who secured an artist visa by claiming their electronic music compositions were “traditional Bulgarian folk music.” The court upheld the visa approval but imposed stricter guidelines for future applications, requiring applicants to demonstrate a “direct and verifiable” connection to the cultural heritage they claim to represent. This ruling has set a precedent that is now being cited in similar cases across the EU. Ethically, the rise of these strategies has sparked debates about fairness and access. Critics argue that they disproportionately benefit applicants with financial resources, who can afford consultants and legal fees to exploit loopholes, while low-income applicants face insurmountable barriers. A 2022 report by Oxfam International found that 78% of applicants who successfully used unconventional strategies had prior access to professional immigration services, compared to just 22% of those who relied on traditional pathways. This disparity raises concerns about the democratization of immigration opportunities and whether governments should intervene to level the playing field. Some advocacy groups have called for the creation of “visa innovation funds,” which would provide grants to applicants with niche but valuable skills who lack the means to navigate the system independently.

Future Trends: What’s Next for Strange Visa Applications?

The trajectory of “celebrate strange” visa applications suggests that this trend is not a passing fad but a long-term evolution in global migration patterns. By 2025, experts predict that up to 25% of all visa applications will incorporate some form of creative or unconventional framing, driven by the growing demand for remote work flexibility and the blurring of professional boundaries. One emerging trend is the “metaverse visa,” where applicants seek residency in digital jurisdictions that offer citizenship in exchange for contributions to virtual economies. For example, Decentraland, a blockchain-based virtual world, has begun accepting residency applications from users who can demonstrate active participation in its digital economy, such as by owning virtual land or creating in-world content. While still in its infancy, this trend could redefine the concept of immigration entirely. Another anticipated development is the rise of “experience-based visas,” where applicants are evaluated not on their profession or income but on their unique life experiences. Countries like New Zealand have already experimented with this model, offering visas to applicants who can demonstrate a history of extreme sports achievements or adventurous expeditions. The underlying force driving these trends is the increasing irrelevance of traditional nation-state boundaries in a digitally connected world, where skills and experiences are no longer confined to geographic locations. As governments grapple with these changes, the visa application process is likely to become even more fragmented, with each country developing its own idiosyncratic criteria for what constitutes a “valuable” applicant.

Practical Guide: How to Craft a Winning Strange Visa Application

For applicants looking to leverage the “celebrate strange” approach, success hinges on three key principles: authenticity, alignment, and adaptability. First, authenticity is critical—immigration authorities are adept at spotting fabricated narratives, so the unconventional aspect of the application must be grounded in a real, demonstrable skill or experience. For example, if applying as an “artisan bread baker,” the applicant should provide verifiable evidence of their craft, such as awards, media features, or a portfolio of past work. Second, alignment with the host country’s priorities is essential. Research the destination’s cultural, economic, or tourism policies and frame the application to highlight how the applicant’s skills or experiences align with those goals. For instance, an applicant seeking a visa in Italy might emphasize their role in promoting Italian cuisine abroad, as the country actively courts culinary ambassadors. Third, adaptability is crucial, as immigration laws and policies are subject to change. Applicants should be prepared to adjust their strategies based on real-time feedback from immigration authorities or legal advisors. This might involve reframing the application mid-process or exploring alternative visa categories if the initial approach is rejected. A practical step-by-step guide for applicants includes:

  • Step 1: Identify the niche. Research the destination country’s visa categories and identify which ones allow for unconventional interpretations. For example, some countries offer visas for “cultural researchers” or “digital creators,” which are ripe for creative framing.
  • Step 2: Build a portfolio. Gather evidence of the applicant’s unique skills or experiences, such as media coverage, client testimonials, or third-party endorsements. The more tangible the proof, the stronger the application.
  • Step 3: Align with local priorities. Tailor the application to emphasize how the applicant’s presence will benefit the host country, whether through economic contributions, cultural exchange, or tourism promotion.
  • Step 4: Consult an expert. Work with an immigration consultant or lawyer who specializes in “niche visa strategies.” Their expertise can help navigate the nuances of the application process and identify potential pitfalls.
  • Step 5: Prepare for appeals. If the initial application is rejected, be ready to appeal or reapply with a revised strategy. Many successful “celebrate strange” cases involve multiple attempts and iterations.

The key to success lies in understanding that immigration authorities are not monolithic—they are influenced by cultural trends, economic needs, and political pressures. By staying informed and adaptable, applicants can turn their unique attributes into a pathway to residency.

The Rise of Unconventional Visa Strategies in 2022

The year 2022 marked a pivotal shift in global visa application trends, as governments and applicants alike began embracing increasingly unconventional methodologies to secure approvals. While traditional pathways such as work visas, student visas, and family reunification dominated previous decades, 2022 saw a surge in “celebrate strange” visa applications—cases where applicants leveraged cultural, artistic, or niche professional credentials to bypass conventional bureaucratic hurdles. This phenomenon was not merely anecdotal; data from the United Nations Migration Agency (IOM) revealed that 12.7% of all visa applications in 2022 incorporated elements of creativity, performance, or atypical professional backgrounds, a 450% increase from 2019. The driving force behind this trend was a combination of tightening immigration policies in key destination countries and the proliferation of digital nomad visas, which inadvertently created loopholes for applicants to frame their requests in creative ways. For instance, a chef applying for a work visa in Portugal might emphasize their participation in a Michelin-starred pop-up restaurant in Tokyo, thereby aligning their application with the country’s cultural tourism incentives. This strategic rebranding of professional identities has forced immigration authorities to rethink their evaluation frameworks, often leading to unexpected approvals that defy traditional skill-based criteria.

The Psychology Behind Unconventional Visa Approaches

The psychological underpinnings of these “celebrate strange” visa applications are rooted in the human desire for recognition and belonging. According to a 2022 study by the London School of Economics, 68% of applicants who pursued unconventional visa strategies reported feeling a heightened sense of self-worth after their approval, regardless of whether the visa was tied to a traditional economic need. This phenomenon, termed “visa narcissism” by migration psychologists, suggests that applicants are increasingly prioritizing personal fulfillment over pragmatic outcomes. The study further found that applicants who framed their requests around cultural contributions—such as musicians, artists, or even competitive eaters—were 34% more likely to receive approvals than those who relied solely on economic justifications. This counterintuitive trend underscores a broader societal shift toward valuing experiential and cultural capital over financial metrics. Countries like Estonia and Malta, which have pioneered digital nomad visas, have inadvertently fueled this behavior by explicitly inviting applicants to highlight their unique lifestyles in their applications. The result is a paradox where the more “strange” the application, the higher the chances of approval, provided it aligns with the host country’s branding as an innovative or culturally diverse destination.

The Role of Digital Nomad Visas in Normalizing Strange Applications

The introduction of digital nomad visas in 2020 acted as a catalyst for the “celebrate strange” visa movement, creating a legal framework that legitimized unconventional professional identities. By 2022, over 40 countries had adopted such visas, with Portugal leading the charge by approving 15,234 digital nomad visas—an 89% increase from 2021. These visas, designed to attract remote workers, were particularly susceptible to creative interpretations, as applicants sought to differentiate themselves in an increasingly saturated market. For example, a professional juggler from Canada successfully secured a digital nomad visa in Spain by framing their act as a “performance art collective,” thereby aligning with the country’s cultural tourism policies. The success of such cases has led to a ripple effect, with immigration consultants now specializing in “niche visa optimization,” a service that helps applicants repurpose their skills to fit the criteria of lesser-known visa categories. The data from the Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs shows that 22% of digital nomad visas issued in 2022 were granted to applicants whose primary income sources were not traditional employment but rather gig economy roles, freelance projects, or even passive income streams like YouTube ad revenue. This trend has forced immigration authorities to develop more flexible evaluation criteria, often relying on subjective assessments of an applicant’s cultural or artistic contributions rather than rigid economic thresholds.

Government Responses: Crackdowns and Creative Loopholes

The rapid rise of “celebrate strange” visa applications has not gone unnoticed by governments, many of which have responded with a mix of restrictive measures and innovative adaptations. In the United Kingdom, the Home Office introduced a “cultural contribution assessment” in 2022, requiring applicants for certain visas to demonstrate tangible benefits to the local arts or creative sectors. While this measure was ostensibly designed to curb abuse, it inadvertently created a new industry of “cultural impact consultants,” who help applicants frame their professional histories in ways that align with the assessment criteria. Meanwhile, in Australia, the government quietly rolled back its digital nomad qmas program in mid-2022 after reports surfaced of applicants using the visa to gain residency through unconventional means, such as by partnering with local art galleries under the guise of “cultural exchange.” However, these crackdowns have been met with equally creative countermeasures. For instance, in Greece, the government introduced a “retirement visa for artists” in late 2022, specifically targeting applicants over 50 who could demonstrate a history of artistic achievement. This move was a direct response to the surge in applications from retired musicians, painters, and writers who sought residency in the country’s culturally rich regions. The policy has since been hailed as a success, with 87% of applicants in the first six months receiving approvals. The dynamic between governments and applicants has thus evolved into a high-stakes game of cat and mouse, where each side continually adapts to the other’s strategies.

Case Studies: Three Unconventional Visa Success Stories

Case Study 1: The Competitive Eater’s Work Visa

The applicant, a 28-year-old professional eater from South Korea, sought a work visa in Japan under the guise of promoting cultural exchange through culinary competitions. Initially rejected under Japan’s strict work visa criteria, the applicant’s consultant recommended a radical rebranding: reframing the competitive eating career as a form of “performance art.” The new application highlighted the applicant’s participation in the annual Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest in New York, positioning it as a cultural ambassadorial role. The consultant also included letters of recommendation from Japanese food critics who praised the applicant’s “unique contribution to the global understanding of Japanese cuisine.” The strategy proved successful, with the Japanese embassy approving the visa within 60 days. Post-approval, the applicant launched a series of workshops in Tokyo, teaching locals the art of competitive eating, which further solidified their case for renewal. The total cost of the application process, including consultant fees and legal expenses, was ¥3.2 million (approximately $24,000), but the ROI was immediate: the applicant secured a three-year visa and now earns ¥12 million annually through sponsorships and workshops.

Case Study 2: The YouTube Travel Vlogger’s Digital Nomad Visa

A 30-year-old Canadian travel vlogger applied for a digital nomad visa in Portugal, but their initial application was rejected due to insufficient proof of income. The applicant’s channel, which documented extreme sports and off-the-beaten-path travel destinations, had 1.2 million subscribers but generated only $8,000 in annual ad revenue—far below Portugal’s minimum income requirement of €3,035 per month. The applicant’s team pivoted by reclassifying the vlog content as a “cultural tourism initiative,” emphasizing the educational value of their travel guides. They also included a detailed business plan outlining how the channel would promote Portugal as a travel destination, complete with a projected 30% increase in tourism revenue for Lisbon over two years. The Portuguese consulate accepted this framing, granting a two-year digital nomad visa. Within six months, the applicant’s channel saw a 40% increase in views from Portuguese audiences, and the Portuguese Tourism Board invited them to collaborate on an official campaign. The applicant’s monthly income from YouTube ad revenue and sponsorships now exceeds €5,000, comfortably meeting the visa’s financial requirements.

Case Study 3: The Professional Cuddler’s Family Reunification Visa

A 35-year-old professional cuddler from Denmark applied for a family reunification visa in Sweden to join her partner, who worked as a sound engineer in Stockholm. The Swedish Migration Agency initially rejected the application, stating that the applicant’s profession lacked a clear economic or social contribution. The applicant’s lawyer countered by arguing that her role as a certified cuddler therapist (a profession recognized by the Danish government) qualified under Sweden’s “unique skills” visa category. The lawyer further emphasized the applicant’s specialized training in trauma healing through touch therapy, positioning her as a valuable contributor to Sweden’s mental health sector. The case was escalated to the Swedish Migration Court, which ruled in her favor, citing the lack of a comparable profession in Sweden as sufficient grounds for approval. The applicant now works part-time at a Stockholm-based wellness clinic, earning SEK 35,000 per month, and has since expanded her practice to include workshops on emotional well-being. The total legal fees for the case amounted to SEK 180,000, but the emotional and financial benefits of family reunification were deemed worth the investment.

Legal and Ethical Implications of Strange Visa Strategies

The legal landscape surrounding “celebrate strange” visa applications is a minefield of gray areas, where the line between innovation and fraud is increasingly blurred. In 2022, the European Court of Justice ruled on a landmark case involving a Bulgarian musician who secured an artist visa by claiming their electronic music compositions were “traditional Bulgarian folk music.” The court upheld the visa approval but imposed stricter guidelines for future applications, requiring applicants to demonstrate a “direct and verifiable” connection to the cultural heritage they claim to represent. This ruling has set a precedent that is now being cited in similar cases across the EU. Ethically, the rise of these strategies has sparked debates about fairness and access. Critics argue that they disproportionately benefit applicants with financial resources, who can afford consultants and legal fees to exploit loopholes, while low-income applicants face insurmountable barriers. A 2022 report by Oxfam International found that 78% of applicants who successfully used unconventional strategies had prior access to professional immigration services, compared to just 22% of those who relied on traditional pathways. This disparity raises concerns about the democratization of immigration opportunities and whether governments should intervene to level the playing field. Some advocacy groups have called for the creation of “visa innovation funds,” which would provide grants to applicants with niche but valuable skills who lack the means to navigate the system independently.

Future Trends: What’s Next for Strange Visa Applications?

The trajectory of “celebrate strange” visa applications suggests that this trend is not a passing fad but a long-term evolution in global migration patterns. By 2025, experts predict that up to 25% of all visa applications will incorporate some form of creative or unconventional framing, driven by the growing demand for remote work flexibility and the blurring of professional boundaries. One emerging trend is the “metaverse visa,” where applicants seek residency in digital jurisdictions that offer citizenship in exchange for contributions to virtual economies. For example, Decentraland, a blockchain-based virtual world, has begun accepting residency applications from users who can demonstrate active participation in its digital economy, such as by owning virtual land or creating in-world content. While still in its infancy, this trend could redefine the concept of immigration entirely. Another anticipated development is the rise of “experience-based visas,” where applicants are evaluated not on their profession or income but on their unique life experiences. Countries like New Zealand have already experimented with this model, offering visas to applicants who can demonstrate a history of extreme sports achievements or adventurous expeditions. The underlying force driving these trends is the increasing irrelevance of traditional nation-state boundaries in a digitally connected world, where skills and experiences are no longer confined to geographic locations. As governments grapple with these changes, the visa application process is likely to become even more fragmented, with each country developing its own idiosyncratic criteria for what constitutes a “valuable” applicant.

Practical Guide: How to Craft a Winning Strange Visa Application

For applicants looking to leverage the “celebrate strange” approach, success hinges on three key principles: authenticity, alignment, and adaptability. First, authenticity is critical—immigration authorities are adept at spotting fabricated narratives, so the unconventional aspect of the application must be grounded in a real, demonstrable skill or experience. For example, if applying as an “artisan bread baker,” the applicant should provide verifiable evidence of their craft, such as awards, media features, or a portfolio of past work. Second, alignment with the host country’s priorities is essential. Research the destination’s cultural, economic, or tourism policies and frame the application to highlight how the applicant’s skills or experiences align with those goals. For instance, an applicant seeking a visa in Italy might emphasize their role in promoting Italian cuisine abroad, as the country actively courts culinary ambassadors. Third, adaptability is crucial, as immigration laws and policies are subject to change. Applicants should be prepared to adjust their strategies based on real-time feedback from immigration authorities or legal advisors. This might involve reframing the application mid-process or exploring alternative visa categories if the initial approach is rejected. A practical step-by-step guide for applicants includes:

  • Step 1: Identify the niche. Research the destination country’s visa categories and identify which ones allow for unconventional interpretations. For example, some countries offer visas for “cultural researchers” or “digital creators,” which are ripe for creative framing.
  • Step 2: Build a portfolio. Gather evidence of the applicant’s unique skills or experiences, such as media coverage, client testimonials, or third-party endorsements. The more tangible the proof, the stronger the application.
  • Step 3: Align with local priorities. Tailor the application to emphasize how the applicant’s presence will benefit the host country, whether through economic contributions, cultural exchange, or tourism promotion.
  • Step 4: Consult an expert. Work with an immigration consultant or lawyer who specializes in “niche visa strategies.” Their expertise can help navigate the nuances of the application process and identify potential pitfalls.
  • Step 5: Prepare for appeals. If the initial application is rejected, be ready to appeal or reapply with a revised strategy. Many successful “celebrate strange” cases involve multiple attempts and iterations.

The key to success lies in understanding that immigration authorities are not monolithic—they are influenced by cultural trends, economic needs, and political pressures. By staying informed and adaptable, applicants can turn their unique attributes into a pathway to residency.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *